© 2023 KLCC

136 W 8th Ave
Eugene OR 97401

Contact Us

FCC Applications
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
Click on a heading to learn more or listen to the show.

City Club of Eugene: How Safe Are Our Dams, Rivers & Reservoirs?

Recorded on: May 19, 2017

Air Date: May 22, 2017
Residents of Western Oregon owe much to a series of federal flood control dams built within the last 75 years.  The US Army Corps of Engineer’s Willamette Valley Project includes 13 dams that regulate 27% of the total flow of the Willamette River, much of it at the southern end of the valley.  Each of the eight Army Corps operated dams in Lane County is estimated to have prevented hundreds of millions or billions of dollars in flood damage.
Completion of the youngest of the dams in the late 1960s marked the end of a devastating cycle of lowland flooding that inundated substantial portions of the valley’s largest cities.  With the end of the periodic floods came a perception of safety and the opening of new land for development.  The Ferry Street Bridge portion of Eugene became a center of residential and commercial development.  In Springfield, the city government recently began projects intended to spark a similar level of development in the formerly flood-prone community of Glenwood.
Approximately forty-five years after completion of the first Willamette Project dam, and about twenty years after the final dam was completed, geologists made a profound discovery about the seismic character of the Pacific Northwest.  Rather than being a relatively inactive component of the Ring of Fire, the region was now determined to be regularly subject to enormous earthquakes, albeit with a recurrence period of several centuries.  Using geological markers, the last major event was discovered to have occurred in the year 1700, just a few generations before permanent European settlement and historical record keeping began.
Those who built the Willamette Project dams did not enjoy the benefits of this latter-day scientific knowledge, and design standards were in accord with a much lower threat level.  Seismic design of dams and reservoirs typically includes accounting for the nature of soil underneath the dam; identifying the presence of land forms that could slide into the reservoir; evaluating the likelihood that ground shaking will generate waves in the reservoir-called seiche, and calculating the required strength of the dams’ structural features.
In Lane County, the Willamette Project dams are the embankment type, resilient structures made of rock fill or other material. This type of construction is thought to have advantages over solid structures in a seismic event.  However, embankment dams are vulnerable to over topping, which can set in motion a process leading to release of the entire reservoir.  Seismic shaking without over topping can also damage an embankment dam and render the facility serviceable until lengthy repairs are completed.
How do those who operate and finance the Willamette Project dams judge the acceptable risk of operating these important flood control facilities in light of geological knowledge that emerged decades after design and completion?  When, if ever, is major reconstruction or complete replacement of a dam in order?  Are the seismic upgrades completed to date sufficient?  Do dams get weaker with age?
The probability of a mega-earthquake in the Cascadia Subduction Zone is quite high-over one-third in the next 50 years.  An earthquake-caused catastrophic dam failure and inundation of populated areas has been described as an “extremely low probability, high consequence event”.  How safe do we want to be?
Erik Peterson is Operations Project Manager, Willamette Valley for Portland District of the US Army Corps of Engineers.
Ray Weldon is Professor in the Department of Earth Sciences at the University of Oregon and a risk consultant for dam operators in California. He is a member of the National Hazard Mapping Team.

Born and raised in Eugene, Anni started at KLCC in 2000 as a reporter and co-host of Northwest Passage. After graduating from the University of Oregon, Anni moved to New York City. She worked in education for several years before returning to her true love, journalism. Anni co-founded and co-hosted Dailysonic, a narrative-based news podcast. She interned at WNYC's On The Media, then becoming WNYC's assistant producer of Morning Edition.
Love Cross joined KLCC in 2017. She began her public radio career as a graduate student, serving as Morning Edition Host for Boise State Public Radio in the late 1990s. She earned her undergraduate degree in Rhetoric and Communication from University of California at Davis, and her Master’s Degree from Boise State University. In addition to her work in public radio, Love teaches college-level courses in Communication and Public Speaking.
Related Content